Welcome to Turnagain Collectibles

Ready to discover your next favorite card? Dive in and explore our latest arrivals, exclusive deals, and collector community. Your next big pull could be one click away!

Sellers link Buyer’s Introduction

Sellers and Consigners

The collectibles featured in our product listings are offered by a variety of trusted sellers. If you’re interested in becoming a seller on Turnagain Collectibles, please review our Sellers page for details and requirements. For further information or to get started, feel free to contact us.

Browse Sports Products Buyer’s Introduction

John-Jason Peterka 2021-22 Upper Deck Young Guns Black Canvas #C385 PSA 10 rookie card

John-Jason Peterka 2021-22 Upper Deck Extended Series Young Guns Black Canvas #C385 PSA 10 Buffalo Sabres RC

$80.00

Tage Thompson Base #28 2024-25 UD Tim Hortons 10th Edition NHL hockey card, ideal for Tim Hortons set builders and Buffalo Sabres collectors.

Tage Thompson Base #28 | 2024-25 UD Tim Hortons 10th Edition NHL Card

$0.50

Owen Power 2024-25 Tim Hortons Base Card #120 Buffalo Sabres

UD 2024-25 Tim Hortons 10th Edition Owen Powers Base #120

$0.64

Victor Olofsson 2019-20 Upper Deck Premier Rookie Auto /3 Buffalo Sabres autograph card

Victor Olofsson 2019-20 Upper Deck Premier Rookie Auto #75/3 – Buffalo Sabres RC On-Card Autograph SP

$150.00

Discover Your Next Treasure

Every piece tells a story and your next chapter is just a click away. Let intrigue lead you through our diverse selection of captivating collectibles.

View Our Collection