Become a Consigner
Consign Your Collectibles For Cash
We do consignment differently—we make it simple, transparent, and stress-free for you. Whether you’re looking to save time or get expert guidance, our consignment options are designed to help you sell smarter and earn more.
No Hassle, More ValueÂ
- Low Fees, High Returns: Keep more of your earnings with our competitive rates.
- Collector Expertise: Our team lives and breathes collectibles, so you can trust we’ll get your items in front of the right buyers.
- Your Cards, Your Call: After 180 days, decide to re-list, get them back, or let us handle the rest—total control is yours.
- Non-Exclusive & Flexible: No exclusivity here—you’re free to explore other sales avenues while consigning with us.
- Â
Choose Your Own Consignment Adventure
Option A: Full-Service, Stress-Free Selling
Too busy to list your cards? No problem! Send your collection to us and we’ll handle everything—listing, pricing, and selling—for a straightforward 10% fee. After 180 days, you decide: re-list, have your cards returned, or let us handle the next steps. It’s that easy!
Too busy to list your cards? No problem! Send your collection to us and we’ll handle everything—listing, pricing, and selling—for a straightforward 10% fee. After 180 days, you decide: re-list, have your cards returned, or let us handle the next steps. It’s that easy!
Option B: Expert Assessment & Guidance
Not sure what your cards are worth? Ship them to our team for a professional evaluation. For a 10% fee (charged only when your cards sell), you’ll get expert insight and recommendations on the best ways to maximize your collection’s value.
Not sure what your cards are worth? Ship them to our team for a professional evaluation. For a 10% fee (charged only when your cards sell), you’ll get expert insight and recommendations on the best ways to maximize your collection’s value.
Option C: Quick Photo Review & Consign with Confidence
Want expert advice before you ship? Just snap some photos of your cards and send them our way. Our team will review your selections and give you straightforward feedback on which cards are best suited for consignment. You’ll enjoy honest, transparent guidance every step of the way—and a simple 10% fee on any cards you choose to consign!
Want expert advice before you ship? Just snap some photos of your cards and send them our way. Our team will review your selections and give you straightforward feedback on which cards are best suited for consignment. You’ll enjoy honest, transparent guidance every step of the way—and a simple 10% fee on any cards you choose to consign!
Option D: DIY & Save
Prefer to take charge? Register as a seller and list your cards yourself. You’ll benefit from our lowest fees (starting at just 8%) and stay connected to the action in the marketplace.
Prefer to take charge? Register as a seller and list your cards yourself. You’ll benefit from our lowest fees (starting at just 8%) and stay connected to the action in the marketplace.
Not sure which adventure fits you best?
Reach out to us anytime—our friendly team is here to help you choose the perfect consignment path. Whether you want hands-on control or just want to sit back and watch your collection sell, Turnagain Collectibles makes it easy and rewarding to get started!
Collectors are searching for what you have to offer—don’t let your gems collect dust any longer!
It’s time to showcase your collection to thousands of eager buyers and turn those hidden treasures into real cash. Flexible options, expert support, and a process designed to make selling easy, ready to cash in?
Become a Consignor
We’ll just need a few details to kick things off—your basic info and your preferred consignment option. Plus, share a bit about the items you want to consign, and if you have photos, feel free to upload them!
"*" indicates required fields
Learn More About Turnagain Collectibles
Â
How do I start consigning with Turnagain Collectibles?
To begin consigning, simply register as a consignor on our website. From there, you can choose the consignment option that works best for you—whether it’s sending us your cards for assessment, providing a photo preview, or listing items yourself.
What is Option A: Full Service, and how does it work?
Option A: Full-Service Consignment
With our Full-Service option, you simply send your cards to Turnagain Collectibles and let us handle the rest—from professional listing and pricing to selling your cards for you.
How It Works:
- Step 1:Â Prepare an Excel spreadsheet with your card details and condition, then email it to us for review.
- Step 2:Â Once accepted, ship your cards to us.
- Step 3: We’ll professionally list your cards on our platform using your own seller account, so you can easily track your listings and stay involved in the entire sales process.
Fees:
A straightforward 10% fee is applied to each sale.
A straightforward 10% fee is applied to each sale.
Listing Time Frame:
Your items are listed for 180 days. After that, choose to re-list, have your cards returned (shipping at your expense), or let us handle any unsold items.
Your items are listed for 180 days. After that, choose to re-list, have your cards returned (shipping at your expense), or let us handle any unsold items.
Best for:
Collectors who want a truly hassle-free experience but still want transparency and the ability to track every sale as it happens.
Collectors who want a truly hassle-free experience but still want transparency and the ability to track every sale as it happens.
What is Option B: Professional Assessment, and how does it work?
Option B: Professional Assessment & Guidance
Let our experts help you unlock the value of your collection! With this option, you’ll receive a thorough evaluation and personalized selling advice—perfect for anyone unsure about card values or wanting to make informed decisions.
How It Works:
- Fees:
No upfront assessment fee. You only pay a simple 10% commission on each card sold. - Process:
Ship your cards to Turnagain Collectibles. Our team will carefully assess their value and condition, then work with you to decide which cards are best to list for sale. - Time Frame:
Once listed, your items remain active for 180 days. After this period, you can choose to re-list, retrieve unsold cards at your expense, or let us manage the remaining inventory.
Best for:
Sellers who want expert guidance on card values and selling strategy, or anyone looking for a confidence boost before listing—without any upfront costs.
Sellers who want expert guidance on card values and selling strategy, or anyone looking for a confidence boost before listing—without any upfront costs.
What is Option C: Photo Pre-Clearance, and how does it work?
Option C: Photo Pre-Clearance
Want a quick, no-commitment evaluation before sending your cards? With our Photo Pre-Clearance option, you can get expert feedback on which cards are best for consignment—saving you time and shipping costs.
How It Works:
- Fees:
No upfront assessment fee. You only pay a simple 10% commission on each card sold. - Process:
Take clear, well-lit photos of your cards and email them to Turnagain Collectibles. Our team will review your images and let you know which cards are best suited for consignment. Once approved, simply ship the selected cards to us for professional listing. - Time Frame:
Cards are listed for 180 days once received. After 180 days, you can choose to re-list, have them returned at your expense, or let us handle any unsold items.
Best for:
Sellers who want a preliminary evaluation and expert advice before shipping their collection—perfect for saving on upfront shipping and making informed decisions.
Sellers who want a preliminary evaluation and expert advice before shipping their collection—perfect for saving on upfront shipping and making informed decisions.
What is Option D: DIY Listing, and how does it work?
The DIY Listing option allows you to manage your own listings directly on our platform. Here’s a breakdown:
- Fees:Â Reduced rates starting at 8%, with fees as low as 5% for higher-value cards.
- Process: Register as a seller on our platform and list your cards yourself. You manage the pricing, communication with buyers, and the sales process while benefiting from our site’s reach.
- Time Frame: Your listings remain active for 180 days, after which you can re-list them or choose to end the listing.
- Perfect for:Â Sellers who want full control over their listings and are comfortable managing their sales to save on fees.
What types of items can I consign?
Turnagain specializes in collectibles like trading cards, sports cards, and other similar items. Before sending, it’s a good idea to check with us about any specific requirements or preferences.
Do I need to insure my items?
Ownership & Insurance Policy for Consigned Items Items remain your property until they are sold. If you wish, you may insure your cards or collectibles during the consignment period for added peace of mind. Please note that Turnagain Collectibles does not provide insurance coverage for consigned products. We recommend that you arrange your own insurance if you feel it is necessary.
What happens if my items don’t sell?
If your items don’t sell within 180 days, you have three options:
- Re-list:
Extend your listing for another period to reach more buyers. - Return:
Request your unsold items be returned to you (shipping costs are your responsibility). - Dispose:
Authorize Turnagain Collectibles to responsibly dispose of or donate unsold items on your behalf.
How do I ship my items to Turnagain for consignment?
Once you’ve registered and selected your preferred consignment option, we’ll provide detailed instructions on where to send your items and how to prepare them for shipping. We strongly recommend using a tracked and insured shipping method to protect your property during transit. Please remember: Turnagain Collectibles does not provide insurance for consigned products, so securing appropriate insurance coverage is your responsibility and is highly encouraged for your peace of mind.
Can I cancel a consignment once I’ve submitted it?
Yes, you can request to have your unsold items returned to you at any time. The cost of return shipping is your responsibility.
If you choose to have any items graded, all grading fees and the cost of shipping to and from the grading service must be paid in full before your items will be mailed back to you. All return shipping and grading-related expenses are the responsibility of the consignor.
How do I get paid for my sold items?
You can choose your preferred payment method when you register as a consigner. Options include bank transfer, PayPal, or other methods as specified. Payments are processed once your items have sold and the transaction is completed.
Can I consign from outside of Canada?
Yes, consignors from outside of Canada are welcome! Please note that you will be responsible for any additional shipping costs and must comply with customs regulations for sending items to Canada.
How do I contact Turnagain Collectibles with questions?
You can reach out to us anytime at [email protected], and we’ll be happy to assist you with any questions or concerns about the consignment process.